On a snowy moonlit night, four shadowy figures ascend a hill up to a lone house. From inside, a knock is heard. Through the point of view of the person inside the house, the door opens to reveal Cuddles, Giggles, Toothy, and Lumpy standing on the porch, holding candles. The group begins singing in a rather off-key fashion, prompting the person inside to slam the door in their faces. A splat is suddenly heard, Giggles begins screaming, and there is a frantic knock on the door. The door opens again to show Cuddles now on his back, his face having been impaled by a rather large icicle hanging over the porch. Toothy tries in vain to revive his dead friend while Giggles continues screaming, her candle apparently setting her head on fire. In the background Lumpy runs away, screaming in fear.